AIR CRE vs. C.A.R.:
Differences That Shape the Deal

A Two Part Series: Part 1

California commercial real estate professionals frequently use either the AIR CRE purchase and sale agreement or the California Association of REALTORS® (C.A.R.) Commercial Property Purchase Agreement. Both forms can get the parties to the same destination, but they do not necessarily take the same route. A buyer, seller or broker who knows one form well can get into trouble by assuming the other form operates the same way. The differences are not merely drafting preferences; they can determine when contingencies expire, whether silence constitutes approval, when escrow must close, and what happens when due diligence produces a demand for a concession. 

 

When Does the Buyer’s Contingency Period Begin and End?

AIR does not use a single clock for all buyer contingencies. The event that starts the applicable period depends upon the contingency. For example, the buyer’s physical or environmental contingency generally begins when the seller delivers the Property Information Sheet, while the financing contingency begins on the Date of Agreement. An AIR transaction can therefore have several due diligence clocks running at the same time, with different starting and expiration dates.



C.A.R. takes a more centralized approach. The buyer’s contingency periods generally run from acceptance, with a 17-day default period unless the parties specify otherwise. The practical consequence is significant: someone accustomed to the C.A.R. calendar can miss an AIR deadline by assuming that all contingencies began on the same date. In an AIR transaction, each contingency and its triggering event should be separately calendared.



Are Contingencies Removed Actively or Passively?

The more important difference may be what happens when the applicable contingency period expires. AIR generally uses passive approval. If the buyer does not timely disapprove a contingency, the buyer is deemed to have approved it. Silence is deemed approval and can therefore change the buyer’s contractual rights without the buyer signing a separate contingency-removal document.



C.A.R. generally works in the opposite direction. The passage of the contingency period does not by itself remove the contingency. The buyer ordinarily must affirmatively remove it in writing, and the seller generally must serve a Notice to Buyer to Perform before obtaining a right to cancel based upon the buyer’s failure to remove the contingency. Someone accustomed to the C.A.R. regime should therefore never assume that a buyer using an AIR contract remains protected merely because no written contingency removal was signed. 



This also explains why forms from the two systems should not casually be mixed. A supplemental form designed for one agreement may assume procedures that do not exist in the other. Before inserting a C.A.R. form into an AIR transaction, or vice versa, the parties should determine whether the supplemental document is consistent with the underlying agreement.



How Is the Closing Date Determined?

AIR generally uses a floating closing date tied to the contingency process. The standard agreement provides for closing a stated number of days after waiver or expiration of the buyer’s contingencies. Extending due diligence can therefore move the anticipated closing date without separately amending a fixed calendar date. If the transaction does not close when required, AIR provides a five-business-day notice and opportunity to cure before termination.



C.A.R. generally states closing as a specified number of days after acceptance or as a fixed calendar date. If the buyer fails to close on that date, however, the seller ordinarily cannot simply declare the transaction over; the seller must first use the contractual Demand to Close Escrow procedure.



Why Does AIR Give the Seller $100?

AIR contains a provision that can look insignificant: $100 of the buyer’s deposit is released to the seller as separate, nonrefundable consideration for entering into the agreement and giving the buyer its broad due diligence right. There is an important reason for it.



AIR gives the buyer broad due diligence rights, which raises a legal question: if the seller is obligated to sell but the buyer retains a broad right to walk away, is the agreement a bilateral contract or an option?  In Steiner v. Thexton, the California Supreme Court looked beyond the label “purchase contract” and considered a transaction in which the seller was obligated to sell while the buyer could cancel in its “absolute and sole discretion.” The Court treated the arrangement as an option rather than an ordinary bilateral purchase contract, although the buyer’s substantial performance ultimately supplied sufficient consideration to make the option irrevocable.  



AIR addresses that concern directly by providing separate consideration for the buyer’s contractual “free look.” C.A.R. takes a different approach by requiring contingency decisions to be exercised in good faith, thereby avoiding the unrestricted discretion that created the issue in Steiner.



The Inspection Finds a Problem. What Happens Next?

Due diligence often produces a second round of negotiations rather than a simple yes-or-no decision. The buyer discovers a roof problem, environmental condition or deferred maintenance and asks for a price reduction, credit, repair or more time. AIR builds a structured “retrade” process into the agreement.



If an AIR buyer disapproves or conditionally approves an item and requests a concession, the seller has 10 days to respond, with silence operating as a rejection. The buyer then has another 10 days to decide whether to terminate, accept the seller’s response, or withdraw the request and proceed. A buyer asking for a substantial credit or price reduction invokes a contractual procedure with defined consequences and deadlines.



C.A.R. generally handles the same problem within its broader investigation and contingency process. Requests for repairs or other concessions and their resolution ordinarily occur within that framework, which uses a default 17-day investigation period. The “retrade” process is not the same under the two forms even when the business negotiation sounds the same.



Who Pays the Closing Costs?

AIR largely predetermines the allocation of common transaction expenses. Escrow charges are generally divided equally; the seller pays specified recording and transfer taxes and the standard title insurance policy; and the buyer generally pays the incremental cost of upgraded title coverage. The form reflects much of traditional Southern California commercial practice.



C.A.R. is more flexible. It identifies common transaction expenses and generally allows the parties to designate whether the buyer, seller or both will pay them. On a large transaction, the allocation of transfer taxes, title premiums and other closing costs can involve substantial dollars, so the differences between the forms can affect the economics of the deal. A party accustomed to AIR’s default allocations should not assume that the same economic deal is built into a C.A.R. agreement.
Part One illustrates the central problem in moving between the two form systems: familiarity can be misleading. The forms may address the same subject but use different clocks, procedures and consequences. Part Two turns to provisions that become particularly important when the buyer changes entities, a tenant will not sign an estoppel, the deal fails to close, or a dispute survives closing.

 

If you would like to receive my free monthly newsletter sign up here.